Nick Kocz's Ridiculous Words
  • SM Thayer
  • About
  • Writing
  • Contact
  • Blog

Different Versions of the Same Painting

7/29/2011

 
Picture
I’ve been trying to limit myself to downloading one Dylan concert per day.  Most days (but not today) I fail utterly to stay within those confines.  If you know where to turn, you can find recordings of hundreds (thousands?) of his shows, and while the recording and performance qualities vary, I’ve been amazed at just how often he totally reconfigures his classic material.  Earlier in the week, I was listening to a few wildly different versions of “Tangled Up In Blue.” They were all performed within just a few years of each other, but so different were the arrangements that it hardly sounded like the same performer. 

[I’d direct you to links of these performances, but Dylan’s Web Sheriff does a pretty good job scouring the ‘net.  Also, to be truthful, Dylan shows can be pretty spotty—some nights, he’s on fire; other nights the fire is reduced to a wheeze.]

Among recording artists, Dylan stands virtually alone in his willingness to re-interpret his material.  Although I’m also a big Beatles fan, I can think of only one instance where Paul McCartney radically re-imagined one of his chestnuts for live performance. 

For years, I envied visual artists.  They have the license to visit and revisit the same rough material again and again.  Think, for example, of Josef Albers (here, and here, and here) or Piet Mondrian (here, and here, and here), or the early American paintings of Edward Hicks (here, and here, and here).  Even Leonardo da Vinci had at least a couple of goes at his “Virgin of the Rocks” material.

By circling and counter-circling around the same material—reconfiguring it slightly but essentially staying within the same structural limits—these artists are forced to search for different aspects and qualities to emphasize.  Subtle differences become hugely important.  If anything, they learn to better understand the conflicts and conundrums that their material poses. 

Viewing such works together can also be fulfilling.  I used to spend a lot of time in the Rothko Room at DC’s Phillips Collection, staring at what some might say were different versions of the same painting.  Each time I’d go, I’d find myself absorbing different qualities of the paintings—one day, their mistiness; on another day, it would be the solidity of their color.

Look at those Albers paintings again.  The structure is the same.  The style and application of color is the same.  But, if you’re like me, you leave those paintings with wildly different impressions. 

I keep wondering if such a thing might be possible within a short story collection.  What would it be like to read, say, eight variations of the same scenario?  What would it be like to write those eight variations?  To be clear, I’m not talking about assembling a linked story collection where one story builds upon a previous story, and so forth.  Instead, each story would start at the same place, and end at approximately the same place.  The characters and settings would be the same, but whereas one story might emphasize, say, the father character, another story might emphasize the mistress.  Or the child.  The outcomes might be different, which would necessarily impart different meanings, but none of the stories would reach outside set parameters to obtain that outcome.

Or would this work better as an anthology?  Would writers of fairly well-known stories be willing to go back to them and create a second story?  Like a Dylan show, the results might be spotty—the high-wire aspect would be part of the challenge. 

One often hears writers say that, after they’ve built their structure and prepared a cast of characters that act in certain fashions, the results of their stories are inevitable.  I’m not sure this is necessarily true.  Just as in life, when minute changes are introduced, wildly different outcomes can result.  The fun would be discovering what those minute changes might be— and discovering what will necessarily remain unchanged.

Or is this just a bit too Oulipo to rev up most people?



Comments are closed.

    Categories

    All
    Adam Johnson
    Alan Cheuse
    Alexander Solzhenitsyn
    Alexi Zentner
    Amber Sparks
    Amy Rowland
    Andrew Wylie
    Andy Warhol
    Anna Snoekstra
    Ann Patchett
    Arsène Wenger
    Aubrey Hirsch
    B.A. Paris
    Barack Obama
    Ben Fountain
    Ben Marcus
    BEST DAY EVER
    Bob Dylan
    Book Reviews
    Bryan Furuness
    Cathy Day
    Children Of Paradise
    Chimamanda Adichie
    Christine Butterworth-McDermott
    Daniel Patrick Moynihan
    Dave Housley
    David Bowie
    David Foster Wallace
    David Lynn
    Donald Barthelme
    Donald Trump
    Don't You Cry
    Ed Falco
    E.M.Forster
    Emma Chapman
    Emmanuel Adebayor
    Flannery O'Connor
    Flash Fiction
    Frank Conroy
    Fred D'Aguiar
    F. Scott Fitzgerald
    Gabriel Blackwell
    George Harrison
    George Saunders
    Gillian Flynn
    Girija Tropp
    Harper Lee
    Heart
    Hillary Clinton
    I Will Never Leave You
    Jacob Appel
    James Lasdun
    James Tadd Adcox
    Jane Fonda
    Jeff Ell
    Jenniey Tallman
    John Cusack
    John Lennon
    John Updike
    Joyce Carol Oates
    J. Robert Lennon
    Julie Lawson Timmer
    Kaira Rouda
    Kate Atkinson
    Keith Banner
    Kenyon Review
    Kim Jong Il
    Kyle Minor
    Lance Olsen
    Len Kuntz
    Lenny Dykstra
    Leslie Pietrzyk
    Lily Hoang
    Lisa Jewell
    Lou Reed
    Luke Geddes
    Mary Kubica
    Melissa Febos
    Milan Kundera
    Molly Gaudry
    Nicholson Baker
    Notes For My Biographer
    Pablo Picasso
    Paula Hawkins
    Paul Maliszewski
    Paul Mccartney
    Philip Roth
    REAL: Regarding Arts & Letters
    Richard Peabody
    Rick Moody
    Robert Kloss
    Robert Smartwood
    Roxane Gay
    Shirley Hazzard
    S.J. Watson
    S.M. Thayer
    SM Thayer
    Stéphane Hessel
    Stuart Dybek
    Submission Fees
    Sven Birkerts
    Tadeusz Borowski
    The Beatles
    The Fall Guy
    The Girls In The Garden
    The Good Girl
    The Official Catalog Of The Library Of Potential Literature
    Thomas Mallon
    Tim O'Brien
    Tony Earley
    Umberto Eco
    Virginia Woolf
    Wells Tower
    Willem De Kooning
    Working Class Hero

    Archives

    August 2018
    January 2018
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    May 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    September 2015
    February 2015
    November 2014
    September 2014
    July 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    May 2013
    March 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.